11 Things Mindfulness is Not
When I first came across mindfulness, I didn’t really get it. I had the Jon Kabat-Zinn definition of mindfulness: “awareness that arises through paying attention, on purpose, in the present moment, non-judgementally”. (Later he added: “… in the service of self-understanding and wisdom.”)
Hmm …. big mouthful! That describes mindfulness in action but still leaves it wide open to misunderstanding.
When I encountered the article “9 Things Mindfulness is Not” by Dimple Dhabalia, I found it helped dispel the many misunderstandings about what mindfulness is. So here is my version.
Mindfulness isn’t . . . time consuming. But the more time you spend practising each day, the faster you will see the benefits.
There is a formal practice and an informal practice. Formal is where you sit and you might focus on your breath, do our ABCD, or the Body-scan or Loving Kindness Meditation. Informal practice can be paying attention to your feet touching the ground as you walk. It can be not picking up your fork or spoon for the next mouthful until you have swallowed the first, in this way paying attention to the food in your mouth rather than diluting the experience with rushing or multitasking.
Mindfulness is dose-dependent —regular practice is more important than anything else. Research shows that just 10 minutes of mindfulness practice per day practiced for four weeks, has significantly positive effects on the brain. That is exciting!
Mindfulness isn’t . . . about stopping your thoughts. But it is about not believing them to be true or to in anyway define you.
My dad rang from Denmark. He wanted to know if you can stop your thoughts. I asked him to close his eyes and to count his thoughts between the time I said “go” to when I said “stop”. For the second exercise, I asked him, again between “go” and “stop” see if he could notice the beginning of a thought, in effect a thought being born.
Afterward, his comment was “It stopped the thoughts!”
In the first part of the exercise, you start to notice the quantity of thoughts and in the second part, you notice that thoughts become coy when you really focus on them. When you give them your full attention, they lose their potency.
You also notice with both exercises that thoughts are just pumped out. You are not in control of what is pumped out but through your attention, you can have some input into what the thoughts focus on.
So, if you think that you are failing at mindfulness because you still have many thoughts happening, you are not! However, if thoughts are racing and they have a strongly unhealthy or negative texture, then feel free to interrupt them. You can do that by shifting attention to your senses, asking: “What are the ears hearing, what are the eyes seeing, what is the nose smelling, what is being sensed by the skin?” You can also place the hand over the heart and just reassure the body: “Dear body, it is ok, we are safe and all is well” (providing you are, of course).
The more mindfulness you practise, the more you are going to not be beholden to the thoughts but see them as interesting arisings, just something that is happening that reflects habitual neural firings. I have found it really useful when I have wanted to change habits to remind myself when the yearning arises that it is just a little old neurological pattern, and not to be taken seriously.
Mindfulness isn’t . . . a relaxation technique. However relaxing is a side effect of practising Mindfulness.
We often think of mindfulness as a relaxation technique — and it is, but that is just a side effect of becoming present, getting out of our head and away from the relentless focus on past and future.
Mindfulness does not take you away from anything, it is about taking responsibility for how you are travelling, interrupting unhealthy mind-states while encouraging healthy ones.
You can be mindful anywhere, at any time, you don’t need a special quiet place however it really helps, particularly at the beginning of your practice.
Mindfulness isn’t . . . about deep breathing.
Paying attention to the breath is often used in mindfulness training because paying attention to the breath makes you present and it is an easy anchor point for our attention. And how you breathe affects the rest of your physiology and your mind-state.
Paying attention to the breath can be an anchor point for noticing what takes us away from being present. The ongoing bringing attention back, focusing on the breath, is a way to strengthen our attention muscle.
Mindfulness isn’t . . . a religion. Buddhism is more a science than it is a religion.
Kabat Zinn and others have been keen to remove all Eastern context from mindfulness. And no doubt that has helped make it as popular as it has become.
However, mindfulness without the Buddhist context is poorer as the insights that you gain from practising mindfulness are expressed so beautifully in Buddhism, and having both the tradition and your practice brings a stronger potency. Ideally, you also have a community to share the experiences with.
There is an invitation to take what you like from Buddhism, not to become a Buddhist but to become better than you already are. And throw the rest away.
Mindfulness isn’t . . . woo woo. You don’t need hairy armpits or incense burning to practise mindfulness.
The practice of mindfulness is one of the most researched modalities for wellbeing and it outperforms cognitive behavioural therapy and all other therapies in terms of increasing our wellbeing. See: “A systematic review and meta-analysis of psychological interventions to improve mental wellbeing.”
It is also backed by neuroscience. This is simply because the Buddha based his insights on carefully observing reality, and as you know science does the same so they should match. And they do!
Mindfulness practice in one way is about using your attention and awareness to change your brain to then change your mind. Naturally, if it weren’t for neuroplasticity, the phenomenon that means the brain is always changing and it changes through what we pay attention to, then mindfulness would not work.
Mindfulness does not make you perfect
The other day I shared a story in a session about me becoming very angry, about ten years ago. One of the participants said: “but you are supposed to be mindful”. Practising mindfulness does not mean we don’t get triggered, and does not mean we don’t experience difficult emotions. It does, however, increase the chance that we will catch them, know the emotions as ours and then deal with them ourselves rather than have them spill over others.
We remain imperfect little beings on a life journey. Mindfulness makes it a little lighter, a little easier, but it does not make us perfect. We already are in our imperfection.
Mindfulness does not make your life perfect and it is not positive psychology
Your life goes on whether you do mindfulness or not. Sad and difficult things still happen. Mindfulness does not subscribe to beliefs like: “The Universe has your Back”. It knows that only universal truths are wise. In other words, the insight has to apply to all human life, not just a few. And that statement would obviously not apply to the 44 million Ukrainians or my sister who got Epilepsy at 13 which totally changed her life trajectory, or the baby dying from starvation.
Mindfulness observes the difficulty, the pain, the sadness, not to ignore it or to dismiss it, but to honour it as a human experience. In the honouring the state starts to fade leaving space for calmer or kinder states. Sometimes it can feel like we have many repetitious and challenging visitors and other times there are delightful guests.
Mindfulness isn’t . . . a flow state. Flow is being one with, mindfulness is observing what is arising, two parts to the experience.
Csikszentmihalyi’ defined the Flow state more than thirty years ago, as: “ a state in which people are so involved in an activity that nothing else seems to matter; the experience is so enjoyable that people will continue to do it even at great cost, for the sheer sake of doing it” (1990)
The Flow state often happens when we have cultivated great skill around an activity that we enjoy. When we are engaged in the activity we forget all about the time, place, and our life outside the activity. We are 100% present, one with the moment.
Mindfulness requires that we observe the reactive part of us, that we observe body sensations, feelings and/or thoughts that arise. In Flow we don’t observe, we just are.
That Flow is not mindfulness doesn’t mean that the flow state is not lovely, it is just not mindfulness!
Mindfulness isn’t . . . something you can do in theory. Just like you can’t learn to play soccer by reading a book.
Mindfulness is not an intellectual concept; it is a state of being where we observe our reactive self as it interacts with the moment. That cannot be done through reading; it is an experience. Knowing about mindfulness is not the same thing as being mindful.
